Looking for the best setup for my rural area
Forum rules
Use the SEARCH function for related topics PRIOR to posting a new topic on the same subject.
Use the SEARCH function for related topics PRIOR to posting a new topic on the same subject.
Looking for the best setup for my rural area
Hey guys, new to the forum but have been doing a LOT of research on this topic. Essentially I purchased a house in a rural area and was told by our ISP that service was available - turns out that couldn't have been further from the truth.
My satellite connection is iffy at best and the 1mb/s or less we get has finally drove me to looking at whatever other options available. The issue I'm running into is that we also do not receive signal inside the house, and what we have outside, albeit 4g LTE most times is still a very weak signal.
Prior to finding you all, I was looking into the MOFI4500, but see now that there's other options using the Sierra Modems for a fraction of the cost. My issue is, before I jump into the 4g Broadband bandwagon, I'm not sure if I need an actual signal booster for signal in my area, or if I use the EM7565 with something like the WE826-T2 OR WG3526 with an external antenna/enclosure. Why go with the 7565 in the WE826 when it's obviously not going to benefit from CAT12? 3xCA?
From my outside signal strength testing, I find a fair amount of noise and weak signal (from -5 to +5 RSNNR and -100-115 dbm respectively). We're using AT&T, and if I can avoid spending $1000 on a booster such as the Cel Fi Go X and instead add external antennas connected directly to the modem/router, I'd rather do that. I'm willing to spend the money to make it work, but saving money never hurts my feelings.
I'd love any recommendations you might have as I'd like to order something asap so we can have a real connection back and get rid of the fairly useless satellite that's been making me pull my hair out since it was installed. I apologize if I this is in the wrong sub forum, as I couldn't really decide the best place for it! Thanks in advance for any recommendations.
My satellite connection is iffy at best and the 1mb/s or less we get has finally drove me to looking at whatever other options available. The issue I'm running into is that we also do not receive signal inside the house, and what we have outside, albeit 4g LTE most times is still a very weak signal.
Prior to finding you all, I was looking into the MOFI4500, but see now that there's other options using the Sierra Modems for a fraction of the cost. My issue is, before I jump into the 4g Broadband bandwagon, I'm not sure if I need an actual signal booster for signal in my area, or if I use the EM7565 with something like the WE826-T2 OR WG3526 with an external antenna/enclosure. Why go with the 7565 in the WE826 when it's obviously not going to benefit from CAT12? 3xCA?
From my outside signal strength testing, I find a fair amount of noise and weak signal (from -5 to +5 RSNNR and -100-115 dbm respectively). We're using AT&T, and if I can avoid spending $1000 on a booster such as the Cel Fi Go X and instead add external antennas connected directly to the modem/router, I'd rather do that. I'm willing to spend the money to make it work, but saving money never hurts my feelings.
I'd love any recommendations you might have as I'd like to order something asap so we can have a real connection back and get rid of the fairly useless satellite that's been making me pull my hair out since it was installed. I apologize if I this is in the wrong sub forum, as I couldn't really decide the best place for it! Thanks in advance for any recommendations.
-
- Posts: 565
- Joined: Thu Aug 30, 2018 8:21 pm
- Location: NE GA Mountains
- Has thanked: 1 time
- Been thanked: 68 times
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
I'm not sure what you mean by signal booster when talking about the various Sierra modems? I assume you mean for cell service? If so, you can just use wifi calling, once you get a better 4G setup for your internet.
If you are going to use AT&T I'd recommend spending the extra 50 bucks and getting the 7565. AT&T typically supports 3xCA on all their towers. It's always better to have more options then less.
Additionally, I'd highly recommend outdoor external antennas. You can start by building a simple setup, without external antennas if you want to just test and make it portable. It's easy to always add external antennas later. The 3dbi rubber ducky antennas in the The Wireless Haven store are leaps and bounds better than the antennas in your cell phone, for what its worth.
If you are going to use AT&T I'd recommend spending the extra 50 bucks and getting the 7565. AT&T typically supports 3xCA on all their towers. It's always better to have more options then less.
Additionally, I'd highly recommend outdoor external antennas. You can start by building a simple setup, without external antennas if you want to just test and make it portable. It's easy to always add external antennas later. The 3dbi rubber ducky antennas in the The Wireless Haven store are leaps and bounds better than the antennas in your cell phone, for what its worth.
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
Also worth mentioning, I'm considering doing something like a conventional gigabit router or mesh home network for the wifi, but if I could get a very strong router combo, I'd much rather have just a single device. In this case, would it be better to just use a M.2 to USB 3.0 enclosure vs something like the we826?
As far as antenna, I'm considering 2 of the 700-2700MHz 15dBi 4G LTE Directional Antenna. Although from my research I was recommended LMR400 for those, I only see LMR200 here on the site. Would I benefit more from the LMR400?
As far as antenna, I'm considering 2 of the 700-2700MHz 15dBi 4G LTE Directional Antenna. Although from my research I was recommended LMR400 for those, I only see LMR200 here on the site. Would I benefit more from the LMR400?
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
Well originally I was going to use a cell phone repeater/amplifier in my setup, but it seems with just the use of external antenna, everyone is getting fairly reasonable speeds. I was going to use a Directional antenna + booster to get signal in the house (I get literally no service inside the house unless near a window) then use a dome antenna on the ceiling to send that service through the house. Then use a SIM 4G LTE router to use as home internet. We use AT&T now for our cell service, so it's a win win - regular signal for phones even without being connected to the network.swwifty wrote: ↑Fri Nov 15, 2019 6:19 pm I'm not sure what you mean by signal booster when talking about the various Sierra modems? I assume you mean for cell service? If so, you can just use wifi calling, once you get a better 4G setup for your internet.
If you are going to use AT&T I'd recommend spending the extra 50 bucks and getting the 7565. AT&T typically supports 3xCA on all their towers. It's always better to have more options then less.
Additionally, I'd highly recommend outdoor external antennas. You can start by building a simple setup, without external antennas if you want to just test and make it portable. It's easy to always add external antennas later. The 3dbi rubber ducky antennas in the The Wireless Haven store are leaps and bounds better than the antennas in your cell phone, for what its worth.
After realizing you can just use external antenna for the routers themselves, I can save myself the booster nonsense and just use the wifi calling. Sorry if my explanation was a little backwards
As far as modem, I definitely decided to go with the EM7576 as I think it will outperform the nighthawk everyone keeps raving about with the use of external antenna. Id rather go with the external antenna at the same time as Im sure I will need them to get any kind of decent speeds. I doubt even the slight upgraded 3 dbm won't help get through the walls and get a strong enough signal to be consistent since I get 0 indoors right now.
-
- Posts: 565
- Joined: Thu Aug 30, 2018 8:21 pm
- Location: NE GA Mountains
- Has thanked: 1 time
- Been thanked: 68 times
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
I don't have any experience with the WE826 acting as an access point, as I have internal dedicated APs.Sexyjesus wrote: ↑Fri Nov 15, 2019 7:26 pm Also worth mentioning, I'm considering doing something like a conventional gigabit router or mesh home network for the wifi, but if I could get a very strong router combo, I'd much rather have just a single device. In this case, would it be better to just use a M.2 to USB 3.0 enclosure vs something like the we826?
As far as antenna, I'm considering 2 of the 700-2700MHz 15dBi 4G LTE Directional Antenna. Although from my research I was recommended LMR400 for those, I only see LMR200 here on the site. Would I benefit more from the LMR400?
In my experience all in one devices typically don't perform as well as separating the functions. Plus sometimes you need the AP to be in the center of the house and that doesn't work when you have a 4G router on the roof, heh.
And yes, go with LMR400 if you are going to bother to setup external antennas. Anything else is typically a waste at these frequencies, unless its only like a 4-5ft run.
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
That's what I figured on the cable - I considered doing everything in one of the roof mounted enclosures like it sounds like you did but honestly got lost on what PCBs and APs and everything needed. Lol just learning one thing at a time right now.swwifty wrote: ↑Fri Nov 15, 2019 7:36 pm I don't have any experience with the WE826 acting as an access point, as I have internal dedicated APs.
In my experience all in one devices typically don't perform as well as separating the functions. Plus sometimes you need the AP to be in the center of the house and that doesn't work when you have a 4G router on the roof, heh.
And yes, go with LMR400 if you are going to bother to setup external antennas. Anything else is typically a waste at these frequencies, unless its only like a 4-5ft run.
My main concern was even outside the signal is weak with a lot of noise which is why I considered the cell booster/repeater first that is up to a 100 dB gain. If I can get good increase with just the antenna, I'll be happy. What I'd LIKE to see is in the 50-70mb/s down club and I'll be tremendously happy.
Currently in my cart I've got the WE826/Em7576, cables and adaptor, and 2 of the antenna I mentioned earlier. I just want to make sure they will all mesh like I hope they will.
I know there can be issues with the length of the run, so is there a certain length I should keep the LMR400 under, or just shortest runs possible? May I ask what exactly you run?swwifty wrote: ↑Fri Nov 15, 2019 7:36 pm I don't have any experience with the WE826 acting as an access point, as I have internal dedicated APs.
In my experience all in one devices typically don't perform as well as separating the functions. Plus sometimes you need the AP to be in the center of the house and that doesn't work when you have a 4G router on the roof, heh.
And yes, go with LMR400 if you are going to bother to setup external antennas. Anything else is typically a waste at these frequencies, unless its only like a 4-5ft run.
-
- Posts: 565
- Joined: Thu Aug 30, 2018 8:21 pm
- Location: NE GA Mountains
- Has thanked: 1 time
- Been thanked: 68 times
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
100db of gain has got to be false advertising. Never heard of thatSexyjesus wrote: ↑Fri Nov 15, 2019 7:51 pm That's what I figured on the cable - I considered doing everything in one of the roof mounted enclosures like it sounds like you did but honestly got lost on what PCBs and APs and everything needed. Lol just learning one thing at a time right now.
My main concern was even outside the signal is weak with a lot of noise which is why I considered the cell booster/repeater first that is up to a 100 dB gain. If I can get good increase with just the antenna, I'll be happy. What I'd LIKE to see is in the 50-70mb/s down club and I'll be tremendously happy.
Currently in my cart I've got the WE826/Em7576, cables and adaptor, and 2 of the antenna I mentioned earlier. I just want to make sure they will all mesh like I hope they will.
I know there can be issues with the length of the run, so is there a certain length I should keep the LMR400 under, or just shortest runs possible? May I ask what exactly you run?
Sounds like you have the hardware you need to get started with a basic setup. Probably only need a sim card and some cables.
I would only worry about lengths of cable of you are NOT using LMR400. LMR400 can go a long ways, but generally its a good idea to keep any cable run you do as short as possible, if possible.
I have LMR400 on my roof. Only a 10ft run, that goes to some cheaper coax that is only 4ft long (I have lightening arrestors and a high pass filter in line)
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
I know that 100 db increase sounds too good to be true. Lol. I'm not sure how well the amplifier in a booster setup (the 100db claim is due to it being a sole provider boost, allowing them allegedly to have more power than an all carrier booster) I just don't see the amplifier creating a good signal without even more noise issues.swwifty wrote: ↑Fri Nov 15, 2019 8:45 pm 100db of gain has got to be false advertising. Never heard of that
Sounds like you have the hardware you need to get started with a basic setup. Probably only need a sim card and some cables.
I would only worry about lengths of cable of you are NOT using LMR400. LMR400 can go a long ways, but generally its a good idea to keep any cable run you do as short as possible, if possible.
I have LMR400 on my roof. Only a 10ft run, that goes to some cheaper coax that is only 4ft long (I have lightening arrestors and a high pass filter in line)
But my problem is, I don't want basic! Haha I'd like a damn good system to see as much speed as possible, and if that takes better equipment, I'll happily spend the money as I see it as an investment! So if you have any recommendations for a very strong setup, I'd be interested! I've even considered a couple of these bastards:
https://www.signalboosters.com/bolton-t ... l-antenna/
26 dbm gain, but not sure if it's overkill. If there's a way to get a solid 100mb/s+ out of a 4g lte network, I'd love to get the right equipment the first time!
-
- Posts: 565
- Joined: Thu Aug 30, 2018 8:21 pm
- Location: NE GA Mountains
- Has thanked: 1 time
- Been thanked: 68 times
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
Maybe they meant a 100x increase in signal strength? That would be 20dbm, which I think could be possible.
Like I said before, forget the signal booster and just setup a connection for your internet, and use wifi calling.
The problem with high gain antennas is they are very directional. If you don't have clear LOS (no trees and no hills) in the way, this is fine, but if not I'd suggest lower gain antennas that cover 700mhz-2700mhz. Multipath is a real issue if you don't have LOS, and high gain antennas can make that worse.
I think you'd be fine just using some of the 11dbi "yagi" antennas that have a radome cover in the The Wireless Haven store. That's what I use, and I've got over 100mbps with them.
Like I said before, forget the signal booster and just setup a connection for your internet, and use wifi calling.
The problem with high gain antennas is they are very directional. If you don't have clear LOS (no trees and no hills) in the way, this is fine, but if not I'd suggest lower gain antennas that cover 700mhz-2700mhz. Multipath is a real issue if you don't have LOS, and high gain antennas can make that worse.
I think you'd be fine just using some of the 11dbi "yagi" antennas that have a radome cover in the The Wireless Haven store. That's what I use, and I've got over 100mbps with them.
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
Will do! Thanks again for the help! My last question would be, any recommendations for LMR400 and where to find it? Trusting amazon is iffy, and Id rather buy the bulk cable (50ish feet) with my own connectors so I can make custom length runs if needed. I guess I could just order one 50ft and the connectors needed. Should I get one side N and one side SMA to avoid needing a jumper from the lmr to the Modem or will a small jumper really matter for performance?swwifty wrote: ↑Sat Nov 16, 2019 8:23 am Maybe they meant a 100x increase in signal strength? That would be 20dbm, which I think could be possible.
Like I said before, forget the signal booster and just setup a connection for your internet, and use wifi calling.
The problem with high gain antennas is they are very directional. If you don't have clear LOS (no trees and no hills) in the way, this is fine, but if not I'd suggest lower gain antennas that cover 700mhz-2700mhz. Multipath is a real issue if you don't have LOS, and high gain antennas can make that worse.
I think you'd be fine just using some of the 11dbi "yagi" antennas that have a radome cover in the The Wireless Haven store. That's what I use, and I've got over 100mbps with them.
-
- Posts: 565
- Joined: Thu Aug 30, 2018 8:21 pm
- Location: NE GA Mountains
- Has thanked: 1 time
- Been thanked: 68 times
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
If you look at various ham radio stores you can find LMR400. I agree I wouldn't trust Amazon for it, unless its from a reputable source.Sexyjesus wrote: ↑Sat Nov 16, 2019 12:56 pm Will do! Thanks again for the help! My last question would be, any recommendations for LMR400 and where to find it? Trusting amazon is iffy, and Id rather buy the bulk cable (50ish feet) with my own connectors so I can make custom length runs if needed. I guess I could just order one 50ft and the connectors needed. Should I get one side N and one side SMA to avoid needing a jumper from the lmr to the Modem or will a small jumper really matter for performance?
I would probably just use a adapter, or a short cable to transition to SMA.
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
I have been told that boosters will not work in the case of an external mimo antenna setup. You might only get one band. I am not an expert, just reporting what WirEng told me.
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
I use a Wilson in-line booster and see my RSRP improve by about 10dBm. Not sure about mimo and you would need a booster for each antenna. I have seen carrier aggregation active on mine with only 1 antenna connected.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B075T ... UTF8&psc=1
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B075T ... UTF8&psc=1
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
Did you install your outside antenna outside? I have been hesitant to put anything outside, considering trying this with the included antenna just sitting inside or even a larger antenna inside. Anything more you can share with your experience -- setup tips or anything that might be helpful to get it working?SliverGT wrote: ↑Tue Dec 31, 2019 2:11 pm I use a Wilson in-line booster and see my RSRP improve by about 10dBm. Not sure about mimo and you would need a booster for each antenna. I have seen carrier aggregation active on mine with only 1 antenna connected.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B075T ... UTF8&psc=1
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
Definitely outside, I'm out in the woods and don't have a strong enough signal to put the antennas inside. I'm currently using a Mofi4500 on AT&T. There really wasn't anything to setup, the booster just plugs in-line between the antenna and modem. I have it installed on the primary antenna input.
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
Thanks- think I'm going to give it a try inside and see. My phone outside gets the same reception as my modem inside, but maybe the booster will help. I'm also on a Mofi/ATT setup.SliverGT wrote: ↑Tue Dec 31, 2019 4:54 pm Definitely outside, I'm out in the woods and don't have a strong enough signal to put the antennas inside. I'm currently using a Mofi4500 on AT&T. There really wasn't anything to setup, the booster just plugs in-line between the antenna and modem. I have it installed on the primary antenna input.
- BillA
- Posts: 1223
- Joined: Sun Dec 01, 2019 6:46 pm
- Location: USA
- Has thanked: 218 times
- Been thanked: 325 times
- Contact:
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
Keep in mind, that a booster will usually boost your signal by about 10db, whether you have a good incoming signal or just noise. So its effectiveness depends largely on the the received signal to noise ratio. In other words if your received signal is above -120db, then your -110db boosted signal may not be high enough quality, thus your data speed would still be low. On the other hand if your received signal is between -100db and -120, then your booster will likely help to a degree. As a general rule, you're better off with an unboosted signal as long as you can mount a sensitive antenna to receive a raw signal below -120db. Course you mileage may vary from other factors too (such as sensitivity of the radio, atmospheric conditions, obstructions, etc).
Re: Looking for the best setup for my rural area
That is essentially what I found. I tried it just sitting on my desk with the antenna over next to the window. I checked the numbers and the signal did get better, but other numbers got worse - and I saw no speed improvement. In fact, I'm pretty sure it got worse. So I returned the setup.BillA wrote: ↑Tue Jan 14, 2020 3:50 am Keep in mind, that a booster will usually boost your signal by about 10db, whether you have a good incoming signal or just noise. So its effectiveness depends largely on the the received signal to noise ratio. In other words if your received signal is above -120db, then your -110db boosted signal may not be high enough quality, thus your data speed would still be low. On the other hand if your received signal is between -100db and -120, then your booster will likely help to a degree. As a general rule, you're better off with an unboosted signal as long as you can mount a sensitive antenna to receive a raw signal below -120db. Course you mileage may vary from other factors too (such as sensitivity of the radio, atmospheric conditions, obstructions, etc).
Adam