Page 1 of 1

Options for plain modem -> ethernet solution (already have a good router)

Posted: Thu Aug 20, 2020 11:46 am
by thebosz
Hi, this is my first post in your great forum!

We just moved to a rural location and I'd like to get a better internet connection. Right now we're using a Nighthawk M1 with two giant yagi antennas. We're getting decent speeds, but at least once a day I have to power cycle the Nighthawk.

Since I can't figure out what's wrong with the Nighthawk, I was thinking that I should replace it with something not designed as a portable hotspot.

My ideal solution is to find a plain modem (as in, not a WiFi router) that just provides an ethernet port. My Nighthawk is pretty far away from my router so I have it set as "passthrough" and it uses the CAT5 in the walls to connect to the router.

I'm on AT&T with the closest tower having Bands 2, 4, 5, 12, 14, 17, 30, 66 according to Cellmapper. The Nighthawk says it's connected to band 14.

In my research, I haven't found a plain modem that fits my needs, so these are my current options as far as I can tell:
  1. GL.iNet GL-X750 (with EC25-AF):
    Pros
    • Pre-made solution that seems very customizable.
    Cons
    • Doesn't support bands 17 and 30
  2. WG3526 with (EC20-G):
    Pros
    • Supports all bands.

    Cons
    • very expensive
    • not as customizable(?)
  3. NEXG H721:
    Pros
    • can buy whatever I want.

    Cons
    • very expensive
    • do I need the wifi modules?
Anyone have any thoughts on what I should do?

Re: Options for plain modem -> ethernet solution (already have a good router)

Posted: Sun Jan 24, 2021 9:27 am
by BDF1234
Hi - Just wondering what you decided to do. I have a similar situation and am trying to figure out the best way to approach it. Thanks.

Re: Options for plain modem -> ethernet solution (already have a good router)

Posted: Fri Jan 29, 2021 10:07 pm
by Didneywhorl

Re: Options for plain modem -> ethernet solution (already have a good router)

Posted: Thu Feb 04, 2021 1:04 pm
by cptskyhawk
Hi -- new to this forum, but I'm in the same exact situation (have a good router, just need a modem).

My biggest question (that I can't seem to find the exact answer for...) is: what service/plan do I need with a cell company to get a sim card I can just stick in a modem?

I'm supposing that I can't just take my current SIM card out of my phone and use it, but is it as easy as just getting another, activating it in another phone, and then putting it in the modem?

Or is there something else I need to tell my cell carrier? I'm on cricket currently, and I've seen from somewhere else during a search here that others have successfully used cricket, but they weren't clear about what plan/service they had with cricket.

tl;dr: what do I tell my cell phone company so I can just use one of their sim cards and they won't disconnect me for using their sim card in an "unauthorized fashion"?

Re: Options for plain modem -> ethernet solution (already have a good router)

Posted: Thu Feb 04, 2021 10:50 pm
by Didneywhorl
Tell the carrier exactly what modem you have and see what plans they offer. Usually data plans for cellular gateway modems are WAY overpriced.

I believe the ATT standalone ipad plan currently works, drop in and go. Just have to set the APN. Visible for Verizon as well.